Ten Fingers · Sites of Goguryeo and Balhae ①
In the first lunar month of 926, the Khitan brought down Sanggyeong, the capital of Balhae. This year marks 1,100 years. Korea has written of that state as the successor to Goguryeo, China as a local regime of the Tang dynasty, and one group of Russian researchers as an independent kingdom of the Malgal (Mohe) people. There are three histories of the same state.
This series does not rule on whose history Balhae is. Nor is it in a position to. Instead it sets side by side what researchers in Korea, China and Russia each write, and on what grounds. It also notes the point in time as of which each account was confirmed. For Korea, we went as far as the text of the high school Korean History textbook under the 7th National Curriculum; for China, a news report relaying a 2004 analysis; for Russia, a 1996 news report introducing a 1994 book. That is the range confirmed this time. For later analyses of Chinese textbooks (a 2018 paper and others), we saw only the abstracts and could not open the full texts. We could not confirm what was written after that.
The Place Today
The site of the Sanggyeong walled city is in Bohai Town (Balhae-jin), Ning’an (Yeongan), Mudanjiang (Mokdangang), Heilongjiang (Heungnyonggang) Province, China. It is 35 km southwest of central Ning’an, and a further 3 km west of Dongjingcheng Town (Donggyeongseong-jin). It was a large walled city whose outer wall ran more than 16 km around. What can be seen today are the stone platform and foundation stones of Wufenglou (Obongnu), the main gate of the palace city; the sites of five palace halls; a well called Babao Liuli Well (Palbo Yurijeong); and the Balhae stone lantern and stone Buddha that remain at Xinglong Temple (Heungnyungsa). The site is too large for full excavation and only the surface has been put in order; there are fields inside the palace city.
The Balhae fortress sites and palace sites this article confirmed are in China’s Heilongjiang Province and Russia’s Primorsky Krai. To see them, one has to go there.

The Record
Balhae was founded in 698 by Dae Jo-yeong. There had been differing views on the founding year, but 698, as recorded in Japan’s Ruijū Kokushi, is the accepted view. The Khitan launched a large-scale attack in the 12th month of 925 and brought Balhae down in the first month of 926 (lunar calendar). Even after Sanggyeong fell, resistance and suppression continued in the provinces until the 8th month of that year. When the last king, Dae In-seon, took the throne is not precisely known.
Three lines of account — as of the dates confirmed
| Korea | “A state that succeeded Goguryeo.” The grounds are the titles ‘Goryeo’ and ‘King of Goryeo’ (Goryeo here being a name for Goguryeo) used in state letters sent to Japan, and the similarity of culture. It also notes that among the population “many Malgal people lived” there. — High school Korean History (7th National Curriculum), National Institute of Korean History |
| China | Claims it was “a local regime of the Tang dynasty in which the Malgal people were the main body.” According to a Korean researcher’s 2004 analysis, Chinese history textbooks (titled Chinese History and Ancient Chinese History) described Dae Jo-yeong “consistently as Malgal.” We could not open the full text of later textbook analyses this time. — Encyclopedia of Korean Culture; Hankuk Kyoyuk Shinmun (Korea Education Newspaper), October 20, 2004 |
| Russia | A 1994 book by Shavkunov and others, 13 researchers in all, viewed Balhae as “an independent kingdom centered on the Malgal people” and criticized both China’s local-regime thesis and Korea’s Northern and Southern States thesis. Archaeologists make up the majority in Russian research, and in 1884 the Society for the Study of the Amur Region set Balhae as the first period of the Middle Ages in Primorsky Krai. — Hankook Ilbo, November 21, 1996; Encyclopedia of Korean Culture |
The Northeast Project was a project officially carried out for five years, from 2002 to 2007, led by the Research Center for Chinese Borderland History and Geography under the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. The information page of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Korea mentions only Goguryeo and does not mention Balhae. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture writes that, through the Northeast Project (2002–2007), the claim was advanced that sought to incorporate Balhae’s history as part of Chinese history. The encyclopedia further reports, as something it was told, that in 2006 China on its own excavated and restored Sanggyeong with a view to UNESCO World Heritage inscription, and that the site of the main gate of the palace city was built in the Tang style rather than the Balhae style.
Within Korean scholarship, too, it is not simple. The encyclopedia writes that there are objections to the formula ‘the ruling class was Goguryeo people, the ruled were Malgal people,’ and it describes the population as of diverse composition, including those of Goguryeo and of Malgal lineage. On September 11, 2026, the Association of Koguryo Balhae held its 86th domestic academic conference at Sungkyunkwan University, and the theme of the first session was “1,100 Years Since the Fall of Balhae: Beyond Reflection, Toward a History of Integration.”
Where Accounts Differ
The largest difference is over the character of Balhae, and the table above shows it. Smaller things differ as well. The year the capital was moved to Sanggyeong is given as around 755 or as early 756, depending on the source. The number of gates of the Sanggyeong walled city is 10 or 11, and the circumference of the palace city 3,986 m or 2,680 m; the encyclopedia and the Northeast Asian History Foundation’s material differ. As for the location of Mount Dongmo, where Balhae was founded, the Chengshanzi Mountain Fortress (Seongsanja Sanseong) in Dunhua is the prevailing view, but there are other views in Chinese scholarship.
We also state what this article could not confirm. We did not see the actual sentences of the current Korean textbooks (2022 revision) or of the current Chinese textbooks. For analyses of Chinese textbooks after 2004, too, we saw only the abstracts. Nor can how Russian scholarship as a whole sees the matter now be stated from a single 1994 book. That is why we did not write “Chinese textbooks say this” in the present tense.

Where Things Stand
Joint Korean-Russian surveys in Primorsky Krai became active from 1993 (the encyclopedia’s “Balhae” entry, 2021). The encyclopedia’s entry “Kraskino Fortress Site, Primorsky Krai” writes that excavation of the Kraskino fortress site began in 1980, led by Boldin of the Institute of History, Archaeology and Ethnography of the Peoples of the Far East, Far Eastern Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, and that from 1992 a Korean excavation team took part, making it a joint Korean-Russian excavation. The traces of a state that the Korean and Chinese accounts and the accounts of Russian researchers describe differently have been sought together by scholars of two of them, Korea and Russia. The story of the Kraskino fortress site continues in the December 2 installment.
The fortress sites of Balhae lie in China and Russia. Since 1992, the team that has dug that soil together with Russian scholars is a South Korean one.
Getting There
- The Sanggyeong site is in Bohai Town, Ning’an, Mudanjiang, Heilongjiang Province. Dongjingcheng Town is 35 km southwest of Ning’an; the site is 3 km west of there.
- What to see: the Wufenglou platform, the sites of Palace Halls No. 1 to 5, Babao Liuli Well, and the stone lantern and stone Buddha at Xinglong Temple.
- China’s visa-free entry (30 days) runs through December 31, 2026. Check before departure whether it is extended into 2027 and what the local visiting rules are. Consulate General of the Republic of Korea in Shenyang +86-24-2385-3388; Consular Call Center +82-2-3210-0404.
What we could not confirm The sentences of the current Korean and Chinese textbooks; the present position of Russian scholarship; the solar-calendar date of the first month of 926; the content of the presentations at the September conference; whether Balhae sites are on UNESCO’s Tentative List.
Use of AI AI was used to prepare the draft. Quotations, figures and dates from sources we opened were checked against the originals, and anything taken from secondary reports is identified as such in the text or the source line. The illustrations between sections were drawn by AI and are labeled as such. We do not create or alter historical photographs.
Next
Sites of Goguryeo and Balhae ② The Ondol of Kraskino — Where a Balhae Room Came to Light (December 2)
⇓ PNG 다운로드
스마트폰의 WIA Code 스캐너로 이 화면을 약 43초 비추면 기사 전체가 폰에 저장됩니다 — 인터넷 없이 읽을 수 있습니다. WIA Code 스캐너 열기
This code contains the original Korean article.





Leave a Reply
Please log in to comment. Log in